jkrun80
Postdoc
Posts: 3305
Age: 65
Reg: 05-07-12
|
09-07-20 07:45 PM - Post#312932
Poll has been posted.
https://bucknellbison.com/poll.aspx?poll=39
|
jkrun80
Postdoc
Posts: 3305
Age: 65
Reg: 05-07-12
|
Women's All-Decade Team 09-07-20 08:03 PM - Post#312934
In response to jkrun80
Since they included the Class of '11, I went with Novacek over Swart. Could have just as easily picked Higham or Horbatuck.
Glad to see they included Klotz.
Edited by jkrun80 on 09-07-20 08:04 PM. Reason for edit: No reason given.
|
Bison137
Professor
Posts: 16147
Reg: 01-23-06
|
09-15-20 05:15 PM - Post#313388
In response to jkrun80
Unfortunately some unknowledgeable voters, or some who just wanted to make the whole process look silly, voted in a few choices that make little sense.
1st Team:
DeBoer
K English
E Mack
K Slagus
R Voss
2nd Team:
A Dotson
R Dumiak
A Kapp
S Romine
K Walker
3rd Team:
T Brugler
L Horbatuck
J Klotz
M McGurk
S Swart
- Kyi English should be 2nd or 3rd team, not 1st
- Rachel Voss, who never made any level of All-PL, doesn’t belong
- Rachel Umiak was never more than a role player off the bench. Good attitude but not someone who belongs on this team
- Tessa Brugler very borderline, being a one-year starter. Not as good to date as Higham or Novacek, If Tessa has another good year she can earn a spot
- Shelby Romine clearly a 1st teamer
- Jacque Klotz clearly a 1st teamer. Did more in two years than almost any of the above did in four. Only one Bison ever had a better first two years than her.
|
jkrun80
Postdoc
Posts: 3305
Age: 65
Reg: 05-07-12
|
09-15-20 09:11 PM - Post#313401
In response to Bison137
I thought the same thing. Somebody did some ballot box stuffing. I could see Klotz on the 2nd team for only having played 2 years, but the others you noted make no sense. Maybe they got Rachel mixed up with her sister (who played at American). How do you leave Romine off the 1st team?
|
Bison54
PhD Student
Posts: 1800
Reg: 11-18-09
|
09-15-20 09:11 PM - Post#313402
In response to Bison137
Kate Walker, Shelby Romine and Jacqui Klotz all should have been first team, although who should come off besides Rachel Voss is tough. Cosima Higham and Joyce Novacek should have been in the top 15, no question, and Rachel V and Rachel D should not.
The jury is out on the current players Abby Kapp and Tessa Brugler but them being in the top 15 is not unreasonable.
|